Search Everywhere: A Semrush SEO Analysis Workflow in 11 Steps
An 11-step Semrush workflow: domain overview, organic research, keyword and backlink gaps, site audit, position tracking and AI visibility, monthly.

This post is Chapter 18 of Search Everywhere: The Practical Guide to SEO, AEO and GEO, the free online edition. Chapter and appendix references link to the matching post.
Google’s tools show your own site through Google’s eyes. To see the competitive landscape (what competitors rank for, who links to them, how big the opportunity is), you need a third-party platform. Semrush is one of the most widely used, and this chapter walks through a complete analysis workflow with it, applied to webocreation.com/.
Semrush estimates its data from its own crawlers, keyword databases and clickstream panels. The numbers are estimates, often quite different from your Search Console figures. Use them for relative comparison and opportunity sizing, not as exact truth.
Note on data in this chapter. Semrush data for webocreation.com/ was not available while writing this book. All tables are illustrative: realistic for a site of this size and niche, but not real. To replace them, export the reports named in each section from a Semrush account and drop the figures in.
Step 1: Domain Overview
Start with Domain Overview (enter webocreation.com/). It summarises:
- Authority Score: Semrush’s 0–100 measure of overall domain strength, combining link power, organic traffic and spam signals.
- Organic search traffic: estimated monthly visits from Google organic results, and the number of ranking keywords.
- Paid search: if the domain runs Google Ads.
- Backlinks and referring domains.
- Traffic trend: 12 months or longer.
- Top organic keywords and positions distribution.
- Main organic competitors.
- SERP features the domain appears in.
Illustrative example: Domain Overview for webocreation.com/ (US database)
Metric Value Authority Score 34 Organic keywords (US) 9,800 Estimated organic traffic (US) 7,400/month Organic keywords (all countries) 41,000 Referring domains 1,240 Keywords in top 3 (US) 290 Keywords triggering AI Overviews where the domain is cited 64 Top country by traffic India, then US, Nepal, Pakistan, UK
Note the country split. OpenCart’s audience is global; looking only at the US database underestimates the site. Switch databases or use the “Worldwide” view.
Step 2: Organic Research
Organic Research shows every keyword a domain ranks for in Semrush’s database, with position, volume, estimated traffic share, URL, intent and SERP features.
Positions report
Filter and sort to answer specific questions:
- Top traffic drivers: sort by Traffic %. Which few pages bring most of the estimated traffic?
- Striking distance: filter positions 4–20 and volume above 50. These are the same quick wins as in Search Console, but with volume estimates and keyword difficulty.
- SERP features: filter by “Featured snippet” or “AI Overview” to see where these features appear for your keywords, and whether you own them.
- Intent: filter by commercial or transactional intent to see whether you rank for money keywords.
Position changes report
Shows new, improved, declined and lost keywords over a period. After a Google core update, this report quickly shows which pages and topics were affected.
Pages report
Groups keywords by URL. Sort by traffic to see your strongest pages, and look for pages with many keywords but poor positions (candidates for improvement) or pages with no keywords (candidates for pruning).
Illustrative example: top pages by estimated traffic
URL Keywords Est. traffic % Notes /40-cool-final-year-college-projects/ 410 9.8% Student audience, off-core but on-brand for “projects” /free-opencart-extensions/ 260 6.1% Core asset /opencart-4-upgrade-guide/ 190 4.4% Core, AI Overview present on main keyword /internship-report-online-earning-part-iv/ 120 2.2% Fragmented series, merge candidate /how-to-pull-products-json-api-opencart/ 95 1.9% Core developer topic /national-policies-health-sector/ 80 1.6% Off-topic; decide move or noindex The pattern this illustrates is common on long-running blogs: some off-topic pages carry real traffic. Pruning decisions should weigh that traffic against topical dilution. Traffic that never converts and pulls the site’s identity away from its expertise is usually worth moving elsewhere.
Step 3: Competitor discovery
Organic Research › Competitors lists domains that share the most keywords with yours, with a “competition level” score. Expect a mix of:
- Direct competitors: other OpenCart development agencies and tutorial sites.
- Platform sites: opencart.com documentation and forum, GitHub.
- Marketplaces: extension and theme marketplaces.
- Generalist publishers: large web development tutorial sites, hosting company blogs.
Pick three to five realistic competitors (sites of similar size and focus) for detailed comparison. Comparing yourself with opencart.com is not useful; comparing with other independent OpenCart experts is.
Step 4: Keyword Gap
Keyword Gap compares up to five domains and shows keywords that:
- Missing: all competitors rank for, you do not.
- Weak: you rank lower than all competitors.
- Untapped: at least one competitor ranks, you do not.
- Strong: you rank higher than all competitors.
- Shared: all of you rank.
The Missing and Untapped lists are the content gap: topics your audience searches for that you have not covered. Export them, remove irrelevant terms, group by topic, and add to your content plan.
Illustrative example: Keyword Gap themes for webocreation.com/ vs three OpenCart competitors
Theme Example missing keywords Combined volume Action OpenCart hosting best opencart hosting, opencart hosting requirements 2,900 New guide (also a partner link opportunity) Payment gateways opencart stripe, opencart paypal checkout 4 2,100 Tutorials per gateway Migration opencart to woocommerce, opencart to shopify 1,700 Migration guides (commercial intent) Errors opencart error permission denied, opencart blank page 1,400 Troubleshooting hub Multi-store opencart multi store setup 600 Tutorial
Step 5: Keyword Magic Tool and Keyword Overview
For each content gap theme, use Keyword Magic Tool to expand:
- Enter the seed (“opencart payment”).
- Use the left-hand groups to see subtopics.
- Apply filters: Questions (for AEO), volume range, KD% below a threshold you can realistically compete at (for a site with Authority Score in the 30s, focusing on KD below 30–40 is sensible), intent, and SERP features.
- Add selected keywords to a Keyword Strategy Builder or list for planning.
Keyword Overview gives details for a single keyword: volume, global volume, KD, intent, CPC, trend, keyword variations, questions, and the current SERP with the ranking pages and their Authority Scores. Use the SERP analysis to judge whether you can compete: if the top results are all huge publishers with strong pages, a smaller site needs a more specific angle.
Keyword clustering
Semrush’s Keyword Strategy Builder (formerly Keyword Manager) groups keywords into topic clusters and suggests which should share a page and which need separate pages, based on SERP overlap. Use it to plan hub and spoke structures (Chapter 5).
Step 6: Backlink Analytics and Backlink Gap
Backlink Analytics shows referring domains, backlinks, anchors, indexed pages (your most-linked pages), and new and lost links over time.
Backlink Gap compares referring domains across up to five sites. Domains that link to several competitors but not to you are the best outreach prospects: they demonstrably link to sites like yours.
Illustrative example: Backlink Gap prospects
Referring domain Links to competitors Type Approach eCommerce resource blog 3 of 3 Resource list Suggest the free extensions list Hosting provider knowledge base 2 of 3 Tutorial references Offer the Turnstile and Cloudflare guides University web development course page 2 of 3 Course resources Suggest the OpenCart developer guide and books Developer forum 3 of 3 Community Participate and answer questions
Backlink Audit flags potentially toxic links. Treat its scores as prompts for investigation, not instructions to disavow. As noted in Chapter 12, Google ignores most spammy links on its own.
Step 7: Site Audit
Semrush Site Audit crawls your site (up to a limit set by your plan) and reports errors, warnings and notices across categories: crawlability, HTTPS, international SEO, Core Web Vitals (lab), internal linking, markup, and AI search readiness checks such as whether AI crawlers are blocked. It produces a Site Health score.
Configure it to:
- Crawl from the sitemap and the homepage.
- Use the Googlebot smartphone user agent.
- Respect robots.txt, but also run once ignoring robots.txt for a complete inventory.
- Exclude parameter URLs you do not want crawled.
- Schedule weekly runs and email alerts.
Illustrative example: Site Audit issues likely on a site like webocreation.com/
Severity Issue Count Note Error Broken internal links 63 Mostly links to old OpenCart forum threads and deleted posts Error Pages returned 4XX 38 Old extension download URLs Error Duplicate title tags 24 Paginated archives and internship report parts Warning Title too long 410 Many tutorial titles exceed 70 characters Warning Low text-to-HTML ratio 290 Heavy theme markup on short posts Warning Pages with only one incoming internal link 180 Old posts deep in archives Warning Images without alt attributes 140 About page and older posts Notice Orphaned pages in sitemap 35 Legacy posts not linked anywhere Notice Pages blocked from AI crawlers 0 No AI crawlers blocked Notice llms.txt found – Present
Do not chase a perfect Site Health score. Prioritise errors on important pages, then warnings that affect many pages through a template.
Step 8: Position Tracking
Position Tracking monitors daily rankings for a chosen keyword list in a specific location and device. Set up a project with:
- 100–500 keywords grouped by tags (topic, intent, priority).
- Competitors added for share-of-voice comparison.
- Desktop and mobile tracking, and local tracking (for example Glendale, AZ) for local keywords.
Key reports:
- Visibility: a weighted score of your rankings.
- Rankings distribution: how many keywords in top 3, 10, 20, 100.
- SERP features: which features appear for your keywords, and which you own. Position Tracking includes AI Overview tracking: whether an AI Overview appears and whether your domain is cited in it.
- Cannibalisation: keywords where multiple URLs from your site alternate.
- Landscape and competitors: share of voice versus competitors.
This is one of the most useful AEO tools available: tracking which of your target queries show an AI Overview and whether you are cited, over time.
Step 9: AI visibility in Semrush
Semrush has added AI-focused features in recent years, sold at the time of writing as an AI toolkit add-on and as part of its enterprise products. Features and names change often, but they generally include:
- Brand visibility in AI answers: how often your brand is mentioned or cited in responses from ChatGPT, Google AI Mode, Gemini and Perplexity for prompts related to your market.
- Share of voice versus competitors in those answers.
- Sentiment: whether mentions are positive, neutral or negative.
- Prompt and topic discovery: which questions in your market AI assistants answer, and which sources they cite.
- Source analysis: which domains AI assistants cite most for your topics, revealing where to earn mentions.
How to use it in this workflow:
- Enter your brand and competitors.
- Review the prompts and topics where competitors are mentioned and you are not.
- Look at cited sources for those prompts. If assistants cite Reddit threads, YouTube videos and a handful of tutorial sites, those are your targets for presence and content.
- Compare with your own fixed prompt set (Chapter 24) for a second opinion.
Illustrative example: AI visibility snapshot
Brand AI mentions share (OpenCart topics) Sentiment Top cited pages Competitor A (large extension marketplace) 31% Positive Extension listings Competitor B (OpenCart agency) 14% Positive Upgrade guide, hosting guide webocreation.com/ 9% Positive Turnstile tutorial, free extensions list Competitor C (tutorial blog) 7% Neutral Install guide Interpretation: the case study’s citations cluster on pages with unique downloads and specific how-tos. Expanding that pattern (an extension plus a definitive tutorial per common problem) is the clearest route to higher AI share of voice.
Step 10: Content tools
- Topic Research: enter a topic to get subtopics, headlines, questions and related searches, useful for building hubs.
- SEO Writing Assistant and SEO Content Template: analyse top-ranking pages for a keyword and suggest related terms, length and readability targets. Use them as a checklist, not a formula; the goal is information gain, not matching competitors’ word counts.
- On Page SEO Checker: compares your page against the top 10 for its target keyword and suggests improvements in content, backlinks, SERP features and technical issues.
Step 11: Traffic and market tools
Traffic Analytics (part of the .Trends add-on) estimates total website traffic from all channels, audience overlap and traffic sources for any domain. Useful for sizing competitors, less precise for small sites.
A monthly Semrush routine
| Week | Task |
|---|---|
| 1 | Review Position Tracking: visibility, top movers, AI Overview citations, cannibalisation |
| 1 | Review Site Audit: new errors since last crawl |
| 2 | Organic Research position changes: new and lost keywords, affected pages |
| 2 | Backlink Analytics: new and lost referring domains |
| 3 | Keyword Gap and Backlink Gap: refresh opportunity lists |
| 3 | AI visibility: mentions and citations vs competitors |
| 4 | Report: combine with Search Console and GA4 in the monthly dashboard |
Key takeaways
- Semrush data is estimated. Use it for competition and opportunity sizing; use Search Console for your own truth.
- The core workflow is Domain Overview, Organic Research, competitor discovery, Keyword Gap, Keyword Magic Tool, Backlink Gap, Site Audit and Position Tracking.
- Position Tracking’s AI Overview tracking is a practical AEO measurement tool.
- AI visibility features show brand mentions, citations, share of voice and cited sources across AI assistants.
- For the case study, the most valuable Semrush outputs would be a Keyword Gap against three similar OpenCart competitors and a Position Tracking project with AI Overview tracking.
Previous: The Rest of the Google SEO Toolbox
Next: The SEO Tool Stack: Crawlers, AI Trackers and Python Scripts
All chapters: Search Everywhere: The Practical Guide to SEO, AEO and GEO






